This is the bit where I complain about The Daughter of Twenty Faces. But I think it’s important to get straight that a lot of the aspects I’ve come to dislike about the series actually developed quite naturally out of the very strongest moments. Credit where it’s due, the writers tried to push the story ambitiously – but I wasn’t taken along for the new style ride.
The obvious killer moment in The Daughter of Twenty Faces was episode 6(spoilers by the gallon), which turned the plot up to 11 and broke things apart. Even during this peak episode I thought moments displayed the lack of accomplishment in execution which has plagued this show. Pushing unrealism too far too often. The gunfight saw some miserable losses, but with little sense of brutality. It was all last gasp heroics. The clichéd traintop fight scene, the (perpetually underwhelming) Tiger succeeding in foolishly losing his weapon, Muta staying alive just long enough. Somehow, even with the bodies piling up, it didn’t feel dangerous.
Frankly the series was never at its best delivering action. And amidst the riveting chaos, I was thinking somewhere in my head, was this story better as a caper? Better when nothing mattered? And then, well shit. The arrival of the brilliant. The episode leapt into the extraordinary. Twenty faces himself in a cocky failure to some egotistical punk. Or so I thought.
This was a hell of a twist. And I think The Daughter of Twenty Faces then critically went from adventuring to twistsville, and didn’t quite survive the transition. Because the setting lost its primacy when it was just background for the latest villain. Because Chiko made less sense without the context of a tale of seeking the world. The moments of average production seemed to stand out more under such circumstances.
Which made me think of the carefully set up betrayal twist of The Tower of Druaga. Druaga might be quite an important show for me in that from episode 2 I knew it wasn’t going to be amazing, but I still looked forward to watching because of what it might throw up. A more madcap series, which pulled off its big plot twist in an ordered fashion. Signposted 10 miles off.
The Daughter of Twenty Faces lacks that constant liveliness, but delivered a massively important twist with a flourish. I didn’t expect surprise from each moment of The Daughter of Twenty Faces, so when it turned up it was near traumatically exciting. But somehow, a bit like Druaga’s “hey, new tower!” coming out of nowhere, stunning but unfulfilling. It had a massive impact, but left me unsure where we were going. This uncertainty is exciting, but the shift in continuity meant that the show needed to be recentred. It almost needed to start again, which did not bode well.
For a show which had already started with a stutter, it seemed a bit much to then veer off into the mundane within a few episodes of its finest hour. Prior to Whitey McHypnotist taking the stage, it looked like the show was conflicted in dealing with the episode 6 fallout. The machine man and the tale of the failed actor suggested mini-arcs in the company of our heroine. Some would work, some would not. With the shift in tone the new idea seemed to be the delivery of something more dramatic. A serious arc to rival the culmination of the capering era. What we got was simply a longer and weaker mini-arc dressed up as something important.
With this new subplot, The Daughter of Twenty Faces diverted into bafflement – into androgynous magic dollwomen. I didn’t mind the machine man, who was unbelievable, but only a brief intrusion, diverting as such. But this lame creepy white haired villain seemed to be major in the plot. And she’d embarrass most series. She’s been a let down. She’s unoriginal, lazily designed, and jumps into by-the-numbers villainous acts almost wilfully.
Then, seeking to overcome the inappropriate by unpredictability, the Man himself cropped up – neatly both being and not being the most obvious candidate. But he appears to have some mystical power of his own. He simply cannot be human. Humans often find loss of blood mildly inconvenient. We have what appears to be a redefinition of the show as pure fantasy, with this new villain spirited away with the end of the arc. Providing only a sense of futility to the whole contrived affair.
I was scoffing at this by-the-numbers bad guy on the “path of hatred” abducting Tome for the lulz and then having a deathbed conversion. There should be a moratorium on humanising villains by having them suddenly go soft at the end. But all the while I was near to being being hooked again. Because the arrival of Twenty Faces came so soon, springing into action unexpectedly. I was left saying to myself – think for yourself, work this our, what’s he doing. And nothing made sense. Off he jumped again and I was perplexed but increasingly disinterested. Absorbed in the moment but ultimately dissatisfied. I’d lost touch with that investment in the world which had allowed me to overlook earlier failings.
Superstrength and so forth didn’t used to be for the good guys. Until The Daughter of Twenty Faces started busting out science as magic, shrugging off wounds and fighting epic “darkness”. Until Twenty Faces stopped being like Chiko and became a pair of silly eyebrows. If you want a “chivalrous” thief then have him play deceptions which border on slapstick, because being knifeproof is just creepy. All the new direction has done is made me dislike Chiko’s idol.
He jumped to certain death. And I willed Chiko. Jump! Jump into the air! After all, the universe has come unhinged, why not try? Right now there’s a tale which isn’t solid enough to feel real, but lacks the budget or the flair for delirious expressiveness. Just an inconsequential arc really. A trick without consequence. A stalling game from a series which is still searching for a new driving logic now that the age of the comicbook thief has passed.


I guess the question is whether or not the age of the comic book really has passed. I’m not sure it makes sense to criticize the “realism” of events in Batman.
But in general, I get the same feeling as you that the tale has lost its mainspring. Although that doesn’t make it less than a very good show, anyway. Here’s hoping that Chiko’s development resumes.
Episode 15 may be the start of something worse, however, if we really do start to get the adventures of the girl detectives. And the thing that has kept me happy with this show is excellent work by Hirano Aya, but I wasn’t that thrilled with even her work in ep15.
The anime has followed the manga plot fairly closely, however, up to now (with some rejuggling) so any complaints about the plot can be laid at the feet of the mangaka. I personally found the white-haired demon fascinating, but I understand people’s resistance.
I do think people underestimate how outstanding the animation of this show is, however. Its style is old-fashioned, but the drawing and animation are spot-on.
By: hashihime on August 9, 2008
at 6:29 pm
It’s always a bad sign (for me) when I start nitpicking over the logic of shows. It tends to mean I’ve stopped thinking about the things the writers want to call attention to. It’s like Batman suddenly got laser vision. It’s not so much more unrealistic than normal, but it doesn’t feel consistent with the feel.
Regarding Hirano Aya, I remain completely won over by Chiko – and have nothing but praise for the way her character has been built up and portrayed. The manga adaptation point is important to the storytelling issues, and not something I’d really considered. I’m not sure I’ll ever get round to reading it, but it’d be interesting to see which bits worked better on the page.
As far as animation goes I don’t think much is ever done wrong, and the art is a big part of that atmosphere which so charmed me. It’s more that I get a feeling of limitation – that they don’t have the opportunity to create jaw-dropping set pieces and extravagant action scenes in the way that shows like Xam’d and Birdy can. I guess that feeling is more noticeable when they’re fighting a monster on a rigged airship than when they’re nicking stuff.
By: coburn on August 10, 2008
at 11:52 am
One thing to be said for the second half, there have been a few really fantastically-animated episodes that surpassed anything early on (especially the machine man fight). Those show real Bones style and ability, but I doubt there’ll be much more of that with the Xam’d crew lighting their cigars on 1000-yen notes.
More importantly though, I don’t think these seemingly random things are all that random. The main thrust in the second arc has been uncovering 20 Faces’ past, and I think that’s been explored pretty well so far. Most of these things (not beach detective Chiko, no…) do relate back to whatever insidious things he and the white-haired girl were doing back in the day. That goes for the machine man too.
My guess? 20 Faces was the victim of his own experiment, and he’s some sort of near-supersoldier who has a hard time dying (the Blassreiter if you will).
If these seemingly unrelated ends really don’t tie up when all’s said and done, I will retroactively change my opinion, but so far it’s still got me.
By: otou-san on August 12, 2008
at 9:08 pm
I actually didn’t mind Tankboy so much. He definitely gave the 20faces mad science angle, and that warehouse encounter was pretty cool. I’m hoping the team have some money saved up for a big finish. Maybe one week we’ll mysteriously see the Xam’d cast spend 20 minutes sitting in a dark room muttering to each other.
I fully expect the laboratory backstory to play a big part later on, and as you say it would be rubbish if it didn’t. It’s really the everything MissWhite did – her leering evilness, her being good at heart, the silly hypnotism. It fit with the way the plot works out, but it just seemed stylistically unappealing. My liking the show has been to a considerable extent tied to its atmosphere and setting, so a development can be consistent with the plot – but still leave me feeling irate on aesthetic grounds.
By: coburn on August 13, 2008
at 11:29 am
[...] he’s looking for Twenty Faces so he can make friends. It seems like the series is getting a tad sloppy lately, but I’m still on board and ready to find out what the hell TF did to himself in the lab to [...]
By: Shameful Otaku Secret! » The End (of Summer) is Nigh on August 19, 2008
at 7:00 pm